On 22 September 2020, Media Defence filed an amicus curiae brief before Mexico’s Supreme Court of Justice, in a case challenging the constitutionality of the country’s national Law on the Use of Force. The brief, filed together with Article 19 (Office for Mexico and Central America), examines international legal standards governing the use of force, in light of a state’s obligations to safeguard freedom of expression, the free press and the right to protest.
Adopted in May 2019, the law grants Mexico’s security forces broad discretion to use force, including in the context of non-violent demonstrations and gatherings. It fails to provide any specific protections to journalists or other third parties who might be present at such events in order to report on them. In June 2019, Mexico’s National Human Rights Commission filed a constitutional challenge to the law, arguing that it violated various protected rights, including freedom of expression and the right to protest.
The brief sets out international and comparative legal standards relevant to the regulation of force, in light of a state’s obligation to safeguard the right to protest and the media’s right to report on it. In particular, the brief examines the following points:
- The current legal framework, which justifies the use of force through the need to maintain social control, should be replaced by one premised on the protection of human rights, including the rights to protest and report.
- Through the use of broad and overly vague terms, the law grants authorities a wide discretion to determine when force is legitimate. This may result in the use of force in circumstances that violate free expression and peaceful assembly rights.
- Journalists reporting at protests perform a vital role as “public watchdog”, gathering and disseminating information including about the conduct of authorities in the event of disorder. Special protections must be afforded to safeguard their ability to observe and report on such events. Any restriction that impacts on the media’s ability to carry out its role as “public watchdog” must be subject to strict scrutiny.
- Harassment, intimidation, violence, arrest and detention have a chilling effect on the media’s ability to cover protests and demonstrations. The failure of the law to protect the right of freedom of expression is particularly concerning in the context of the widespread violence perpetrated against journalists in Mexico.
Mexico is one of the deadliest countries in the world for journalists and reports of police abuse, impunity and corruption are common. Protests and public demonstrations are particularly dangerous, with journalists subject to assault, arrest and detention. It is hoped that this case will be an opportunity for the Supreme Court to strengthen the protections afforded to journalists in the face of that violence.
The amicus brief (Spanish) can be found here.
Media Defence is pleased to announce that the Dow Jones Foundation has decided to renew their support for our legal work with a further $10,000 grant. Thanks to the Dow Jones Foundation and its continued support, we can be more equipped to respond and provide legal assistance in support of press freedom around the world. […]
European Court Finds Turkey Violated Cumhuriyet Journalists’ Rights to Liberty and Security, Freedom of Expression, Detained in the Crackdown Following July 2016 Coup
The European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) has held that Turkey violated the Article 5(1)(c) and 10 rights of ten journalists working at the prominent Turkish newspaper, Cumhuriyet. The journalists were arrested and detained in the government crackdown following the July 2016 attempted coup. Media Defence intervened as a third party in the case, along […]
Welcome to the latest instalment of our ‘Partners’ blog series. In this series, we interview some of our partners from around the world about their crucial and fascinating work in freedom of expression. This time, our Legal and Grants Officer Emmanuel Vargas spoke to lawyer Hanifi Baris of TOHAV (Toplum ve Hukuk Araştırmaları Vakfı/Foundation for […]