Media Defence Logo

CLOSE

Media Defence Files Intervention Before Constitutional Court of Colombia in MOVICE Case

Media Defence Files Intervention Before Constitutional Court of Colombia in MOVICE Case

Media Defence has filed an intervention before the Constitutional Court of Colombia, in the case of Marcos Evangelista Pinto v. National Movement of Victims of State Crimes (MOVICE). The case concerns a mural painted by MOVICE activists in Bogotá, which referred to the magnitude of extrajudicial killings carried out by the Colombian Army from 2000 – 2010. The mural featured pictures and names of high-ranking officers, including the army’s Chief Commander, and the question “Who gave the order?”. The army quickly showed up and painted over the mural. MOVICE then publicised this act of censorship and was sued by one of the commanders pictured in the mural.

The case raises important questions around the protection of the right to freedom of expression of journalists and organisations who act in defence of the public interest, as well as the applicable international standards for the balance between this right and the honour or reputation of high-ranking public officials accused of the commission of crimes whilst in office in a democratic society.

The intervention draws on international and comparative legal standards to examine the following points:

  • The context of extrajudicial executions of innocent civilians by members of the Colombian army known as “false positives”;
  • The right to freedom of expression related to matters of public interest;
  • The balancing between the rights to reputation and freedom of expression in matters of public interest;
  • The protection of public interest speech and the chilling effect.

 

Colombia currently ranks at 130 out of 180 in RSF’s World Press Freedom Index. Journalists in the country are often subject to state harassment and violence. The government has also been known to use force on journalists and peaceful protesters.

 

The intervention can be found here.

If you are a journalist or citizen journalist in need of support, please click here.

Recent News

Meet the Team: Laura McCartan, MEL Officer

We caught up with Laura McCartan, who recently joined Media Defence as our Monitoring, Evaluation and Learning Officer. She talks about what inspired her to join the organisation, and what she’s looking forward to in her role. Can you tell us a little about yourself? I’m Laura McCartan, and I’ve been working at Media Defence […]

Read

Las Volcánicas: sued for reporting on allegations of sexual abuse

Matilde de Los Milagros Londoño and Catalina Ruiz-Navarro are two Colombian journalists, founders of the news outlet Las Volcánicas. After extensive research, on 24 June 2020 they published a report denouncing eight cases of alleged sexual abuse and harassment against women by the renowned Colombian filmmaker Ciro Guerra. Soon afterwards Guerra launched a series of […]

Read

Guinea: Our Application Following the Internet Shutdowns

Media Defence files application to ECOWAS Court against Guinea following government-ordered internet shutdowns Media Defence has filed an application to the ECOWAS Court on behalf of four applicants after Guinea cut internet access across the country in March 2020, and again in October 2020. The shutdowns were imposed at critical moments in Guinea’s democracy. In […]

Read