On 22 September 2020, the Supreme Court of Colombia handed down judgment condemning the violent repression of anti-government protests in November 2019, during which security forces attacked, arrested and detained protesters, human rights defenders and journalists reporting on the national demonstrations. The Court ruled on a tutela*, filed by several citizens and civil society organisations, which sought to challenge the actions of the security forces and uphold constitutional rights of peaceful protest, freedom of expression and protection of the press.
Media Defence and Robert F. Kennedy Human Rights (RFKHR) submitted an amicus brief to the Supreme Court in the case. Our brief, supporting the position of the six organisations who worked on the tutela, referenced international legal standards on the protection of journalists reporting on protests. In particular, it analysed the scope and nature of the obligations on authorities to guarantee the effective enjoyment of this right, including in the context of the use of force.
In its judgment, the Supreme Court found that the security forces, particularly Colombia’s Mobile Anti-Riot Squadron (ESMAD), had engaged in consistent acts of aggression against peaceful demonstrators and journalists covering the demonstrations. The Court underlined the constitutional and international legal guarantees regarding the use of force by law enforcement during demonstrations, noting that these activities must meet the standards of proportionality and necessity. It also ordered Colombian authorities to apologise publicly for the violent acts perpetrated by the security forces.
Notably, the Court also made a number of orders aimed at ensuring systemic reform, including:
- That authorities, including the president, must adopt norms mandating the neutrality of the executive branch with regards to peaceful demonstrations and protection of the rights to freedom of expression, press freedom and peaceful assembly;
- That the president must initiate a dialogue with the applicants and other interested persons aimed at restructuring rules on the use of force during demonstrations. If the parties are not able to reach agreement, the government must issue a regulation that reflects international and constitutional standards within 60 days;
- Noting the serious impacts of unlawful police action on the rights of peaceful protesters, that the police and Prosecutor’s Office must create a protocol to limit the police’s use of force in the context of demonstrations and establish external monitoring of their action.
As emphasised by Media Defence and RFKHR, this case raised important issues in relation to the right to freedom of expression as protected by Colombian Constitution and international law, including the urgent need to control the actions of the authorities during protests and the serious harassment faced by journalists working in Colombia.
To download the amicus brief of Media Defence and RFKHR, click on this link.
To download the full text of the judgement, click on this link.
*A tutela is a constitutional injunction that aims to protect fundamental constitutional rights when they are violated or threatened by the action or omission of any public authority.
UNESCO has released a new report on “The “misuse” of the judicial system to attack freedom of expression”. The report takes an in-depth look at the patterns and challenges surrounding the rise of abusive litigation, and makes a number of recommendations. To mark its release, we explore our own experience tackling legal threats to freedom […]
Lawmakers, academics and citizens are becoming increasingly aware of the threat posed by disinformation and malinformation. ‘Disinformation’ refers to falsehoods spread deliberately to stoke distrust or promote an agenda. It is a widespread issue, overshadowing elections everywhere from Brazil to the USA, fuelling hate speech, such as in India, and impacting stock prices around the […]
This article was written by Esma Yasar, a Kurdish lawyer working for Media Defence’s partner organisation TOHAV. Esma Yasar took part in Media Defence’s fellowship programme, which hosts human rights lawyers from our funded partner organisations all over the world. Freedom of Expression and Press Freedom in Turkey Turkey is one of the most restrictive […]