Jean Wyllys is a Brazilian journalist who writes for Counter Punch, amongst other prominent newspapers and magazines. He is also a researcher at Open Society Foundations and an LGBTQ+ activist. His research focuses on disinformation and the rise of authoritarian governments. Wyllys was forced into exile after receiving homophobic hate speech and death threats whilst serving as one of Brazil’s first openly gay members of parliament.
What does freedom of expression mean to you?
Freedom of expression is, for me, one of the pillars of a truly democratic society. Without intellectual, artistic and/or political freedom of expression, there is no real democracy. However, the right to freedom of expression implies a responsibility on the part of those who exercise it. No one should be able to use their freedom of expression to lie, slander, defame and propagate hatred, and expect to get away with it. Hate speech and lies threaten individuals and collectives. In short, freedom of expression is not and cannot be freedom of oppression. The limit of freedom of expression is the human dignity of those at whom the expression is directed.
Could you tell us about the defamation against you?
From the moment I became a member of the Brazilian parliament, far right groups subjected me to a defamation campaign, online violence, and harassment. They did this in response to me being the first openly gay social-democratic parliamentarian in a majority right-wing environment.
The defamation campaign against me is ongoing. In fact, any Twitter profile that criticizes Bolsonaro or other powerful far right individuals receives hateful, defamatory remarks, and comments that are based on misinformation.
In 2022, I was sued for my comments on social media after an MP agreed with the proposition that a Nazi party should be legalised and said that Germany had made a mistake by criminalising the Nazi party.
Media Defence is supporting the appeal against the lawsuit that is ordering me to pay damages in this defamation case. For me, it is very important to have an organisation like Media Defence by my side in fighting defamation through judicial means. Since we can’t contain all misinformation, we must at least hold powerful public officials that are spreading lies and promoting harassment judicially accountable.
How has this case affected your work?
It has affected my whole life. It forced me to abandon my mandate in Congress. To leave behind my family and friends. It has drastically affected my mental health. In other words, it has totally altered my destiny. My luck is that the years of living in poverty have made me a survivor, someone capable of reinventing themselves, and continuing the fight.
What are the biggest issues you see regarding freedom of expression in Brazil at the moment?
On the one hand, a big issue is the disinformation programmed by the extreme right. This includes lies, slander, conspiracy theories, denialism and historical revisionism. On the other hand, the silencing of political and artistic expression, especially of minority and powerless groups. So there is a perversion of the notion of freedom of expression. Additionally, and as a consequence, powerful individuals are permanently harassing those who bring to light truthful information and who promote diversity.
This interview was translated from Portuguese. Read the original version here.
If you are a journalist in need of support as a result of your reporting, please click here.
LPM Lintas: Indonesian student magazine shut down after reporting on sexual harassment investigation
At the State Institute of Islamic Studies (IAIN) in Ambon, Indonesia, student magazine LPM Lintas was shut down in March 2022 after publishing the results of an investigation into allegations of sexual harassment at the university. The investigation relied on the testimony of dozens of students. The university’s rector subsequently issued a decree to close […]
Durante años, la periodista Claudia Julieta Duque fue sometida a una prolongada campaña de tortura psicológica a manos de la extinta policía secreta colombiana, el Departamento Administrativo de Seguridad (DAS). Desde 2001, Duque se enfrentó a una persecución implacable, desde el secuestro hasta la incesante invasión de su intimidad, pasando por la vigilancia ilegal de […]
For over two decades journalist Claudia Duque was subjected to a prolonged campaign of psychological torture at the hands of the now-defunct Colombian secret police, the Department of Security (DAS). Since 2001, Duque faced relentless persecution — from kidnapping to the ceaseless invasion of her privacy, encompassing illegal surveillance of phone calls, emails, and bank […]