Media Defence Leads Intervention at European Court to Protect Journalistic Sources

MLDI led a coalition of several interveners to urge the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights to recognise enhanced protection for journalistic sources.

The Media Legal Defence Initiative worked with the applicants’ lawyers and led a coalition of interveners in the case ofย Sanoma v. the Netherlands, before the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights.

Our intervention urged the Grand Chamber to overturn an earlier judgment by a lower chamber at the Court which had found that police did not need judicial authorisation to compel evidence from media.

We argued that this set a dangerous precedent. The Grand Chamber agreed with our submissions and unanimously overturned the earlier judgment, holding that journalistic materials enjoy enhanced protection from search and seizure.

“This ruling was an acid test for the court and for media freedom across Europe,” said Geoffrey Robertson QC, counsel for a coalition of intervening organizations. “It sets a high benchmark for protection of journalistic materials and will force police and prosecutors across Europe, from Russia to France, to change their practices.”

The Grand Chamber judgment can be foundย here.

Click hereย for the intervention by MLDI and the other interveners.

Recent: Interventions & Amicus Briefs

Banned, Fined, Imprisoned: Saba Sutidze on Georgia’s Press Crackdown

In this edition of Press Freedom Advocates, Media Defence speaks with Saba Sutidze, a human rights and media lawyer at the Tolerance and Diversity Institute, about the escalating crackdown, the

Case Challenging Impunity in the Killing of Journalist Lรฉo Veras Reaches the IACHR Six Years After His Death

On the sixth anniversary of the killing of Brazilian journalist Lourenรงo โ€œLรฉoโ€ Veras, the Institute for Environmental Law and Economics (Instituto de Derecho y Economรญa Ambiental – IDEA) and Media

French Court of Appeal Dismisses Surgeonโ€™s Defamation Lawsuit Against Marsactu and Mediapart

Aix-en-Provence Court of Appeal dismissed surgeon Michel Assorโ€™s defamation lawsuit against Marsactu's article published in 2024.

A free press is essential for the protection of human rights.