CLOSE

Media Defence intervenes before Colombian Constitutional Court in a challenge to the law on criminal defamation

Media Defence intervenes before Colombian Constitutional Court in a challenge to the law on criminal defamation

Media Defence has filed an intervention before the Constitutional Court of Colombia in a constitutional challenge to two provisions of the Colombian Penal Code. Under Articles 220 and 221 of the Penal Code, individuals accused of making “dishonourable accusations” can face up to four-and-a-half years in jail. Those accused of libel face up to six years in jail.[1] The constitutionality of these provisions was challenged by Colombian non-governmental organisation El Veinte.

The case raises important questions around the effect that criminal provisions, in particular those imposing custodial sentences, have on the exercise of freedom of expression.

Noting that the Constitutional Court had already decided on the question of proportionality with respect to these laws, the intervention focuses on the chilling effect of those provisions. It argues that criminal provisions on defamation are open for abuse and put journalists at risk of receiving custodial sentences for legitimate reporting on matters of public interest.

The intervention notes that criminal defamation laws are per se in contradiction with international human rights law, and constitute an unjustified interference with freedom of expression. It also emphasises that the prospect of receiving a custodial prison sentence for reporting means journalists often end up self-censoring.

The intervention argues that this chilling effect constitutes a form of prior restraint which is not permissible under the American Convention on Human Rights. Prior restraint amounts to an especially severe limitation of freedom of expression as it curtails speech even before it is placed before the public.

If you are a journalist in need of legal support, please click here.

 

[1] Penal Code of Colombia, last updated on 20 April 2023 (accessible here).

Recent News

The Legal Minefield of Investigating Tech: Insights from Our CEO

At the 2025 International Journalism Festival in Perugia, Media Defence CEO Carlos Gaio joined a panel discussion titled “When Removing Bylines Isn’t Enough: How Can Journalists Safely Investigate Tech in 2025?” (Watch in full below). The conversation explored the growing threats facing those who report on powerful technology companies — and the tools they can […]

Read

El impacto de nuestras cirugías de litigio: Una conversación con el abogado Jorge Ruiz del Ángel 

El año pasado entrevistamos al abogado mexicano de derechos humanos Jorge Ruiz del Ángel sobre su experiencia participando en una de nuestras cirugías de litigio y su incorporación a nuestra red global de abogados/as. Nuestras cirugías de litigio  Las cirugías de litigio son un componente clave del trabajo global de Media Defence y se ofrecen […]

Read

Conoce al equipo: Marta Cabrera

Nos complace enormemente dar la bienvenida a Marta Cabrera, una destacada abogada especializada en derechos humanos, quien se une a nuestro equipo como consultora legal. Con años de experiencia en las Cortes Interamericana y Europea de Derechos Humanos, Marta aporta una perspectiva invaluable a nuestro trabajo. En esta entrevista de la serie Conoce al equipo, […]

Read