Media Defence welcomes the recent decisions of Turkey’s Constitutional Court, finding the detention of journalists Mehmet Altan and Sahin Alpay (who have been in prison for over a year) to be unlawful. The Constitutional Court’s decisions should be important steps forward, leading to the release of the journalists, but the lower courts have refused to implement the judgments, claiming that the Constitutional Court has exceeded its authority.
“This non-implementation of the Constitutional Court judgments by the lower courts, despite the principles of Constitutional law, is a worrying sign, indicating that there is no effective remedy in Turkey to protect journalists from unlawful use of criminal investigations and detentions because of their critical reporting.” said Ayse Bingol, Legal Officer of Media Defence. “It also raises concerns around the independence and impartiality of the judiciary, since the lower courts’ refusal to implement came shortly after several critical statements were made by high-level government officials against the Constitutional Court.” she added.
In an attempt to resolve this ‘constitutional crisis’, lawyers for the journalists have urged the Constitutional Court to make a further ruling on implementation to ensure the immediate release of the journalists. Whether or not the Court will accede to this request and whether the lower courts would then comply with the Constitutional Court’s orders remain unclear.
Due to the rapid decline in press freedom in Turkey, Media Defence has been active in the country, ensuring its legal support is accessible to journalists, media outlets and bloggers under threat for their reporting. We are currently supporting a number of cases before the domestic courts and have joined a number of third party interventions currently pending before the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) concerning the cases of detained journalists in Turkey.
Media Defence urges the state authorities to act in accordance with Turkey’s obligations under international human rights law to respect and protect rights and freedoms of journalists; to comply with the Constitutional Court judgments; and to immediately release the detained journalists. The detained journalists’ cases have been pending before the ECtHR for over a year. We hope that this event will lead the Court to determine the cases and affirm the fact that the detained journalists are entitled to their right to freedom of expression.
ECtHR finds Russian regulator unlawfully issued warnings against newspaper reporting on extremist organisations
The European Court of Human Rights has handed down judgment today in the case of Novaya Gazeta and ZAO Novaya Gazeta v Russia.
The last 12 months have brought into sharp focus the extent to which media freedom is under threat. At Media Defence we see these challenges on a daily basis. In the last year, we have seen them accelerate due to the pandemic, with unscrupulous regimes introducing oppressive legal measures under the guise of tackling disinformation, […]
Call for Consultants: Trainer at Litigation Surgery on Digital Rights Freedom of Expression Online (French-Speaking)
Purpose of the consultancy contract The purpose of the consultancy contract is for a French-speaking trainer to create recorded presentations and host discussions sessions for lawyers in West and Central Africa on digital rights and freedom of expression online. Background Media Defence’s vision is a world where journalists no longer face legal challenges that threaten […]