Brazil’s Supreme Court: blocking journalists on social media by public authorities is unconstitutional

Brazil’s highest court has recognised that the former President, Jair Bolsonaro’s, practice of blocking journalists on social media was unconstitutional, in a case brought by the Brazilian Association of Investigative Journalism (Abraji), represented by lawyer Tais Gasparian, with Media Defence’s support.

Although the case was closed because Bolsonaro is no longer in office, the decision sets out important principles for journalists’ access to officials who govern through social media. Below is Abraji’s statement on the decision.

This statement was first published by the Brazilian Association of Investigative Journalism (Abraji). Read the original in Portuguese.

Justice Cármen Lúcia of Brazil’s Supreme Federal Court (STF), the country’s highest court, has recognised that the President of the Republic’s practice of blocking journalists’ profiles on social media is unconstitutional, and that it violates the protection of press freedom and the right to information. The decision responds to a collective writ of mandamus (a legal action to protect rights against unlawful acts by public authorities, brought on behalf of a group) filed by the Brazilian Association of Investigative Journalism (Abraji), which challenged at least 65 blocks imposed by then-President Jair Bolsonaro (in office 2019–2022) on journalists and communicators between 2018 and 2021.

The decision, dated 12 November 2026, dismisses the petition filed in July 2021, but reaffirms journalists’ right of access. It took more than five years. Jair Bolsonaro has not been President since January 2023, and his profile was not transferred to his successor, so the STF found that the case had become moot. In other words, although the Justice recognised that Abraji was right in its claim, the claim can no longer be granted.

Abraji, represented by lawyer Tais Gasparian and supported by Media Defence, had asked the STF for an injunction to unblock the profiles of the journalists it had identified and to prohibit the President from imposing new blocks. The action was based on monitoring that showed the blocks were a systematic practice used to silence critics and shut down public scrutiny.

In May 2020, Abraji began monitoring the profiles of journalists and media outlets blocked by public authorities on Twitter. From September that year the monitoring became continuous, and by November 2022 it had recorded 385 blocks. Although the monitoring covered a range of public authorities, Jair Bolsonaro always topped the list.

The STF accepted Abraji’s argument that the public interest of authorities’ official social media accounts must be recognised. In the decision, the Justice states that the responsibility of the office of President extends to the President’s presence on social media, especially in the case of Jair Bolsonaro, who used his Twitter (now X) profile to announce political, governmental and administrative actions, and to share opinions and interact with users in ways that reflected the exercise of his office.

In the Justice’s view, a block means exclusion from public debate. “Excluding someone from the virtual agora in which the then President of the Republic presented himself on governmental and therefore political matters, matters of the polis, which belongs to everyone, means cutting the citizen off from the public statements of someone who undertook to serve as the representative of the very citizen he seeks to remove from that public space,” the decision states.

“No one governs a Republic of one’s own. A citizen is not removed from public debate out of ideological or political liking or dislike,” the Justice adds.

Abraji’s research showed that the blocks often came in retaliation for questions or criticism that journalists had put to the former President. Rodrigo Carvalho, London correspondent for TV Globo, Brazil’s largest broadcaster, said he was blocked by Bolsonaro in December 2020 after asking him on social media when Brazilians would have access to the Covid vaccine.

Abraji’s President, Ana Carolina Moreno, said: “Abraji accepts the news that the case has been dismissed, but welcomes the substance of the decision, which makes clear that no elected representative may exclude citizens from public debate about the government, wherever it takes place. That includes members of the press, whose freedom to gather information in the public interest in the course of their work must be guaranteed.”

Tais Gasparian said: “Justice Cármen Lúcia’s decision is consistent with the reasoning she has expressed for years on the role of the President of the Republic in a democratic state. By announcing his acts of government on social media, and making it his means of communication as head of the nation, the President cannot shut citizens, still less journalists, out of that communication. A ruler’s acts are subject to public scrutiny, and journalists play a vital role in reporting what he does and says.”

Media Defence’s response

Carlos Gaio, CEO of Media Defence, said: “The Brazilian Supreme Court recognised that elected officials cannot arbitrarily block journalists on social media. More and more officials use social media to govern, and they cannot shut journalists out of public debate for asking difficult questions. Other journalists and their lawyers facing the same problem can now point to this reasoning. We’re proud to have supported Abraji and its members in this case.”

Quotes from the decision, Abraji and Tais Gasparian are translated from Portuguese.

Overcoming oblivion: Carlos Correa on detention, dismissal and the fight for press freedom in Venezuela

Venezuelan journalist, professor, and human rights activist Carlos Correa speaks to Media Defence about his detention and enforced disappearance, the criminal case against him and press freedom in Venezuela. It

We’re Hiring: Development Director

Location: London, with hybrid working. We will also consider candidates based in the Netherlands with the correct right to work permit. We combine home working and office-based working to suit

Lawyers from across Sub-Saharan Africa gather in Nairobi for Litigation Surgery 

From 2 to 4 October 2026, Media Defence, the Robert & Ethel Kennedy Human Rights Center (KHRC) and the Vuka! Coalition for Civic Action brought together 16 lawyers in Nairobi,

A free press is essential for the protection of human rights.